The forgotten variable? The relationship between public administration traditions and large-scale social policy reforms. The case of childcare reform in Germany and Italy

Autor principal:
Daniel Fernández Serrano (European University Institute)
Programa:
Sesión 2, Sesión 2
Día: lunes, 22 de julio de 2024
Hora: 12:30 a 14:15
Lugar: FRANCISCO DE VITORIA (142)

Current views of welfare state recalibration emphasize popular demand as the main explanatory factor for social policy reform. New constituencies of highly educated professionals demand new welfare policies: childcare, HE, parental leave, ALMP or new VET programs. However, why have only a subset of countries in central and northern Europe recalibrated their welfare states successfully towards new needs? While these approaches emphasize demand. They cannot explain how governments use the administrative apparatus and cooperation with other civil society actors (welfare governance) to deliver public services. Specifically, it is necessary to investigate where, how and when welfare state policies mutate into new programs. In the last decades most countries have initiated to encourage the use of childcare facilities. This is due to new social changes: new lifestyles, the fall in fertility and the integration of women into the labor market. What is most interesting is that these policies were implemented in totally different ways. While in Germany they have instituted a fully public system through NGOs. In Italy the system is hybrid private-public, implemented at the local level but with large differences between municipalities. While coverage in Germany is relatively high, Italy could not increase childcare coverage successfully. We argue that successful welfare reform is not only about the politics of welfare, but also about the governance of welfare1. In this paper we explore the administrative development of childcare policies in Germany and Italy in the last decades. We analyzed the causal mechanism through which political demands were translated differently by different administrative infrastructure and diverse civil society and implementing actors. Finally, the consequences of this administrative heritage are analyzed in relation to the implementation of the European recovery funds for childcare.

Palabras clave: local public administration, childcare, subnational governance